2014 - Commonwealth: Stevenson
2014 - Freedom: Misericordia
2013 - Commonwealth: Messiah
2013 - Freedom: Misericordia
2012 - Commonwealth: Messiah
2012 - Freedom: Misericordia
2011 - Commonwealth: Messiah
2011 - Freedom: Eastern
2010 - Commonwealth: Messiah
2010 - Freedom: Manhattanville
2009 - Commonwealth: Messiah
2009 - Freedom: Eastern
2008 - Commonwealth: Messiah
2008 - Freedom: Eastern
2007 - Commonwealth: Messiah
2007 - Freedom: Manhattanville
2006 - Commonwealth: Elizabethtown
2006 - Freedom: Scranton
2005 - Commonwealth: Messiah
2005 - Freedom: Wilkes
2004 - Commonwealth: Messiah
2004 - Freedom: Scranton
2003 - Commonwealth: Messiah
2003 - Freedom: Scranton
2002 - Commonwealth: Messiah
2002 - Freedom: Scranton
2001 - Commonwealth: Messiah
2001 - Freedom: Scranton
2000 - Commonwealth: Messiah
2000 - Freedom: Scranton 0, Drew 0 (Penalty Kicks - U. of
Scranton 3, Drew 1)
1999 - Scranton
1998 - Elizabethtown
1997 - Drew
1996 - Elizabethtown
1995 - Scranton
1994 - Scranton
1993 - Scranton
1992 - Scranton
1991 - Scranton
1990 - Scranton
1989 - Scranton
1988 - Franklin & Marshall
1987 - Franklin & Marshall
1986 - Scranton