2019
2018
2017
2016
2015 
 
2014
Commonwealth
Player of the Year: Austin Galaska, Messiah
Rookie of the Year: Kyle Hakum, Elizabethtown
Coach of the Year: Troy Boone, Messiah
 
Freedom
Player of the Year: Matt Molinari, FDU-Florham
Rookie of the Year: Ryan Tracy, King’s
Coach of the year: Mark Birtwistle, Eastern
 
2013
Commonwealth
Player of the Year: Mike Burkhart, Messiah
Rookie of the Year: Jonathan Bensing, Lebanon Valley
Coach of the Year: Chris Ramer, Stevenson
 
Freedom
Player of the Year: Billy King, FDU-Florham
Rookie of the Year: Jeff Slanovec, Misericordia
Coach of the year: Roger Kindel, FDU-Florham
 
2012
Commonwealth
Player and Rookie of the Year: Avery Jones, Albright
Coach of the Year: Jon King, Alvernia
 
Freedom
Player of the Year: Nick Sica, Manhattanville
Rookie of the Year: Gonzalo Sanchez, Manhattanville
Coach of the year: Nikhal Kumar, Manhattanville
 
2011
Commonwealth
Player of the Year: Matt Burkhart, Messiah
Rookie of the Year: Bobby Ranken, Alvernia
Coach of the Year: Troy Boone, Messiah
 
Freedom
Player and Rookie of the Year: Juan Ayala, Manhattanville
Coach of the Year: Nikhill Kumar, Manhattanville
 
2010
Commonwealth
Player of the Year: Matt Burkhart, Messiah
Rookie of the Year: Matt Burkhart, Messiah
Coach of the Year: Troy Boone, Messiah
 
Freedom
Player of the Year: Mike Cresci, Manhattanville
Rookie of the Year: Lem Randall, Manhattanville
Coach of the Year: Nik Kumar, Manhattanville
 
2009
Commonwealth
Player of the Year: Kurt Amen, Elizabethtown
Rookie of the Year: Nick Iacono, Elizabethtown
Coach of the Year: Keith Marks, Elizabethtown
 
Freedom
Player of the Year: David Suarez, FDU-Florham
Rookie of the Year: Derek Stewart, Alvernia
Coach of the Year: Roger Kindel, FDU-Florham
 
2008
Commonwealth
Player of the Year: Mike Heller, Albright
Rookie of the Year: Geoff Quinque, Elizabethtown
Coach of the Year: Keith Marks, Elizabethtown
 
Freedom
Player of the Year: Greg Stockley, FDU-Florham
Co-Rookies of the Year: Javier Vargas, Manhattanville; Jeff Herrick, Manhattanville
Coach of the Year: Rogel Kindel, FDU-Florham